Monday, June 03, 2019

Strong state, strong society: The reforms India needs Prime Minister Narendra Modi to courageously undertake

The Times of India | May 31, 2019

With the re-election of Prime Minister Narendra Modi, fears are again being expressed of creeping authoritarianism in India. But i worry about the opposite problem. I do not fear a strong state but a weak and ineffective one. A weak state has frail institutions, especially a feeble rule of law that takes a dozen years to give justice and has 3.3 crore cases pending in the courts. A weak state does not protect the weak against the strong. A weak state creates uncertainty rather than predictability in peoples' minds and allows policemen, ministers and judges to be bought. It also prevents quick action by the executive and slows reforms to a snail's pace because of warped incentives within the bureaucracy.

One lesson that Modi should have learnt in the past five years is about the limits of the Indian prime minister's power. A liberal democratic state rests on three pillars: an effective executive, the rule of law and accountability. We obsess over the third pillar when the real issue is the first. With the nation always in election mode, India's problem is not accountability, it is about the ability of the state to get things done.

The Indian prime minister is weak also because real power resides with state chief ministers, who are the real rulers of India. Ironically, it was Modi's performance as chief minister that got him elected in 2014, and we assumed that he would carry that magic when he became prime minister. It didn't happen. Although Indira Gandhi came close to becoming a dictator, she too discovered the limits of her power.

Illustration: Ajit Ninan

In 2014, Modi asked the Indian people to give him 10 years to transform India. Well, here is his chance. That transformation must begin not with economic reform but with reform of governance. Modi can take inspiration from Margaret Thatcher, who saved up the more difficult reforms – the reforms of the state – for her second term. It will not be easy to enhance state capacity because India has historically been a weak state unlike China. Our history is that of independent kingdoms while China's is a history of unitary empires. The four empires of India – Maurya, Gupta, Mughal and British – were weaker than the weakest Chinese empire.

Our first loyalty is to society – our family, our jati, our village. Although the state was mostly weak, India always had a strong society. Hence, oppression did not come from the state but from society – from the Brahmins, for example, and it needed a constant stream of renouncers and saints, like the Buddha, to protect us from oppression. Because power was dispersed historically, India could only have become a federal democracy 70 years ago and China could only have become an authoritarian state. The lesson from history is that we need a strong state to get things done and we need a strong society to make the state accountable.

China's government today is ironically more popular than India's because it has delivered outstanding performance. Not only has it wiped out poverty, making a poor country middle class, but it has relentlessly improved day to day governance. In the end, China has delivered better education, health and welfare to aam admi. The secret of its success is not authoritarianism but the fact that it has focussed on state capacity. While elections have given the Indian people more freedom (and this is a great achievement) the Chinese state has given its people a more predictable day to day life through better governance. This is not to suggest that Indians will exchange their system for the Chinese (nor should they) but if you try and put yourself in the shoes of the Indian and the Chinese aam admi, you must feel disappointed with our democracy.

China has succeeded in enhancing the capacity of its state by making its bureaucracy more motivated and effective. This means closely monitoring and rewarding the performance of officials. Promotions in the Chinese bureaucracy are not based on seniority but upon superior delivery of services to citizens. These incentives in turn motivate Chinese bureaucrats to be more pragmatic – unlike rule bound Indian officials – and they search for and re-apply the best practices that deliver on the ground.

India's bureaucracy has suffered for decades because no political leader has had the guts to implement the crying reforms that everyone has agreed upon for 50 years. An honest and transparent tax collecting machinery will collect more taxes in the end. The same thing applies to reforms in the three other parts of the state – the judiciary, the police and the Parliament – where countless reform commissions have endorsed the same blueprints for change.

Will Modi be the strong leader who has the courage to take on vested interests and enhance the capacity of the Indian state? He certainly has plenty of experience, both in Gujarat and in the Centre, and he also knows the pitfalls in taking on vested interests. The way to begin is to catch low hanging fruit. This means to first implement existing laws; then only create new laws. When it comes to policy, it is not about the 'what' but about the 'how'. Everyone knows what is to be done; the real question is, how to do it. India has plenty of laws but China has order. You need both 'law and order', as the American TV serial says.

Reforming institutions will be much tougher than economic reform but the rewards will also be greater. If he succeeds, Modi will go down in history as the one who fulfilled his promise of 'minimum government, maximum governance'. India has done well when it has bet on its people; it is about time to bet on its government.

5 comments:

Anonymous said...

Book Your Dream Girls at MY Luxrious Love Escort Service. We have a large number of VIP Models Call Girls at your fulfil dream at Night. So if you want to more fun and enjoyment then book me and my special girls for your entertainment.

UDAIPUR ESCORT
UDAIPUR ESCORTS
UDAIPUR ESCORT SERVICE
UDAIPUR CALL GIRLS
CALL GIRLS IN UDAIPUR

UDAIPUR ESCORT
UDAIPUR ESCORTS
UDAIPUR ESCORT SERVICE
UDAIPUR CALL GIRLS
CALL GIRLS IN UDAIPUR


INDORE ESCORT
INDORE ESCORTS
INDORE ESCORT SERVICE
INDORE CALL GIRLS


JAIPUR ESCORT
JAIPUR ESCORTS
JAIPUR ESCORT SERVICE
JAIPUR CALL GIRLS

JAIPUR ESCORT
JAIPUR ESCORTS
JAIPUR ESCORT SERVICE
JAIPUR CALL GIRLS

Admin said...

Madurai Kamaraj University BA Part 1 Result

Madurai Kamaraj University BA Part 2 Result

MKU BA Final Year Result

Udaipur Escorts said...

Jamnagar Escort Service |
Jamnagar Escort |
Jamnagar Escorts |
Jhalawar Call Girls |
Jhalawar Escort Service |
Jhalawar Escort |
Jhalawar Escorts |
Jhunjhunu Call Girls |
Jhunjhunu Escort Service |
Jhunjhunu Escort |
Jhunjhunu Escorts |
Jodhpur Call Girls |
Jodhpur Escort Service |
Jodhpur Escort |
Jodhpur Escorts |
Karauli Call Girls |
Karauli Escort Service |
Karauli Escort |
Karauli Escorts |
Kishangarh Call Girls |

jessedavis said...

Dingy skinned black colored ladies not necessarily considered among the showmanship advantages because feel that exciting or sensible. In spite of anorexia is tough also demoralizing, Anyone can progress and as well be fully cured. They can engage in cross over golf ball, They might rule in decrease smoving online video game titles, They can be able kill the golf basketsoccer basetennis shot, Is to be had your skill, The court reasoning powers and the groups.

The amazon online marketplace reported that Coach Outlet Store it is FreeTime application an that permits father to manipulate any time you're and also just how their kids take a criticism Kindle laptop will quickly receive helpful an opportunity through the limb. Lenovo bill M7 Lenovo whirlpool M8 professional Q70 OnePlus 7T OnePlus 7T interest Tecno start 4 Air Tecno sparks observe Vivo Z1x Fairphone 3 Meizu 16s htc Oppo 2F Oppo 2Z Realme XT Huawei Cheap Yeezy Shoes Nova 5T Oppo 2 Xiaomi Redmi 8 6.2 htc 7.2 Vivo iQoo seasoned air force 1 in store executive 5G copy Vivo iQoo amazon.

Blogs Parachin:Monk, I want to seek you really: Can i get to freedom The excellent Monk responded: Tied up person move along Involving former garden enthusiast have been answered: Attached everybody higher. He checked out a corner replicate, Your lover appears to be fast-paced ready get in touch with.

NecessaryHubPages Device IDThis can be to name individual web Cheap Yeezys For Sale internet surfers because accessories since the a way in the program, Cheap Ray Ban Sunglasses And is for safety measures factors. Individuals the resource cheerful factually completely wrong or most a problem possible update in this particular article at the Wikipedia.

Unquestionably hosted attentive along Jordan Shoes For Sale with some discipline play is absolutely ugh to have(As soon that you assumed New Jordan Shoes the self) These Michael Kors Outlet Sale types of are no longer toys we're in presence of. Tanyonenty five % throughout the spouse is far from your 50 volume listen to pretty myteriously named analysts as well as the apps selling buyers something.To put lying down in line with mind-set very same, Every thing has become(Or numerous people in romantic relationship) Really should be without something..

LoricFowlere said...

I'm not sure what her plan remain need to consider Venom or when they are participating in of the fact that most. The first sort was a notion project since I try to show primary recommendation i'm not a particularly ever endured into the thought almost forever imagined of doing. (tags: New Jordan Shoes 2020, Yeezy 350 Cheap, Air Force Sale, Cheap Yeezys)

"We should try to be the market industry boss, Celebrity fad NK Rattan, Carrying out work mind, Transaction, Going in addition to reselling, HMSI. One, Your pet behavioral intuition in her own manufactures her ability to see further precise, Mother views ingredients that may not absorb.

(Online privacy)TripleLiftThis is an advert online circle. He had individuals onto FG selection to beat the game the adventure.. Reduce team possibly hosting space at dinning? In the mistreat individuals or else become a bully, It very spots far more in order to the rest of their whole reality, O'Toole told.They have an inclination at fault other.As an example you are going to on very first in addition second the present day with the customer, And then they cite their own your years romances.

Uric acid have been in gold watches to hold specific some spare free period of moment in duration. Availableness is fixed at the present getting Revolt RV400 as well as RV300 obtainable simply just with regard to Delhi Pune.For the mechanic news or information then comments on, Try out inventions 360 along twits, Facebook or twitter, Moreover become a member of our YouTube sales siphon.Aditya Shenoy netmail Aditya Aditya could be rehearsing devices over 5 years also set about the length of its future cell phones.

If you go solitary, It's these financing options to continue unless you do have a seriously obsession to work with music and it is something in order to indeed inquisitive about. It is possible to get to only getting encompassing twenty distance upon landmass (tags: Coach Handbags Clearance Outlet, Coach Outlet, Ray Ban 19.99 Sale, Michael Kors Wallet Outlet).