Sunday, December 11, 2011

When democracy won but the people lost

The past two weeks witnessed a remarkable spectacle in which India’s democracy won but India’s people lost. On November 24, the government announced a bold reform to allow 51% foreign stake in retail. It triggered off a storm of protest across the political spectrum, and eventually forced the government to back down and suspend the reform. During the entire debate no one asked why China and dozens of countries welcome foreign investment in retail. The defeat of the government means that Indian consumers have lost a chance for lower prices, India’s farmers have lost the prospect of higher returns, a third to half of India’s food will continue to rot, and millions of unemployed rural youth have been denied jobs and careers in the modern economy. It is also a severe blow to the future of reforms in India.

It does seem odd that democracy should win and people lose. But democracy’s great flaw is that it is easily captured by vested interests. In the 1980s, labour unions captured it to ban computers in government offices, banks and insurance companies. Today the powerful kirana trade has succeeded by funding opposition to a policy that was patently in the nation’s interest. The kirana lobby created an atmosphere of fear. The same fears were expressed during the 1991 reforms. If the government had given in then, India would not have lifted 200 million people out of poverty; not raised 300 million into the middle class and not made India the second fastest growing major economy.

Indians today are victims of the primitive “mandi system” which escalates food prices by 1:2:3:4, resulting in the world’s highest gap between the price a housewife pays and what the farmer receives. What a farmer sells for 1 is sold at the mandi for 2, which becomes 3 at the kirana store and 4 to the consumer. When you pay Rs 20 per kilo for tomatoes, the farmer gets only Rs 5. As tomatoes travel from the farm to the mandi to the bania, each middleman gets his cut. The price spread varies by commodity and season, but studies show that the gap is less in countries with modern retail. This is because large foreign retailers usually buy directly from farmers without middlemen. Thus, they can pay Rs 8-10 to farmers for the same tomatoes and sell them for Rs 15-17 to consumers, and still make a profit. Some middlemen will lose out but P Chengal Reddy, secretary-general of Consortium of Indian Farmers Associations says, "India has 60 crore farmers, 120 crore consumers and half a crore traders. Obviously, government should support farmers and consumers. FDI in retail will bring down inflation.”

It will also save food from rotting. Global retailers have perfected a cold distribution system. By investing in thousands of cold storages and air-conditioned trucks, they will reduce farm wastage, and bring a revolution in transport, warehousing, and logistics, as they have done in major countries like Argentina, Brazil, Chile, China, Indonesia, Malaysia, Russia, and Thailand, which have allowed 100 per cent FDI in multi-brand retail since the 1990s.

In none of these countries have small stores been wiped out; nor are there complaints of predatory pricing by supermarkets—the two fears expressed in the past two weeks. According to a recent study, small outlets have grown by 600,000 in China since 2004. “In Indonesia, after ten years of opening FDI in multi-brand retail, 90 per cent of the business remains with small traders, while employment in the retail and wholesale sectors grew from 28 million to 54 million from 1992 to 2001”. Kirana stores continue to succeed because they offer personalized service, give credit and deliver to the house.

This issue goes beyond shops and supply chains to whether India’s democracy can throw up the sort of leaders who can reach out and persuade opponents about much needed reforms. This was a test for the Prime Minister. He made a bold decision to usher in a retail revolution. He gave a choice to the states to opt out of the reform. He may have failed this time but if he is courageous he will persist and win the next time because he is doing the right thing for the nation.

75 comments:

Highonclouds said...

Mr. Das
Thank you for the post. You've very well highlighted some of the things we are going to lose by not allowing FDI in the retail sector- more jobs, prosperity for farmers, better supply chain networks, more investment in infrastructure, inflation control etc. to name a few.

I guess one of the things the retail lobby is missing here is finding a more inclusive growth model for the kirana traders. Almost everywhere in the world, people are resistant to change - not a surprise if a change of this magnitude was dealt with so much of opposition. ITC was probably in a similar situation few years back when they were procuring wheat for their Aashirwaad brand aata. When they thought of the e-choupal project, the devised a model where they maintained all the key intermediary players and convinced them they won't really be worse off. ITC assigned them different roles- somewhat similar and somewhat different to their existing roles. For example some of them were made sanchalaks and samyojaks (coordinators & collaborators) who handled the physical transportation of the goods and provided other logistical support in exchange for a commission.And those who worked hard were eventually much better off than their current circumstances. Here again, ITC like other modern retailers,counted on the distribution and operational efficiencies for better outcomes for everyone involved.
I feel that if the supporters of retail FDI had come up with some such brilliant idea, some of the folks from opposition could have been converted to give it a try. And once it had taken off, the rest would have just followed.
Thanks
Rajneesh
P.S. I am these days reading your book - The art of being good; Quite liked it so far.

Ankur said...

I have a very fundamental question here. Why can't Indian Retail giants do this? Why is FDI so important to build modern retail in India Companies like Reliance, FutureGroup, etc are well placed to do in India what Walmart did in USA. Is the cold storage technology as rare as nuclear technology? Are the retail business processes as much a trade secret as Coca-cola's formula? Why can't Indian companies do this?

Vijay Mohan said...

Dear Ankur ,

Sorry , If you find it rude.

Why don't you follow your own suggestions!

Why to instruct and expect from others.

Let people do what they want to do and suffer from results.

Don't forget , Competition fosters innovations.

Thanks
Vijay Mohan

Vijay Mohan said...

Dear Rajneesh,

If I run some business , then Please let me follow my way .

Profits are rewards. If I don't serve people well , I wont get rewards/Profits

Let consumer be the judge .

Similarly , let the retailers decide there own ways to maximize the profit.

IN competitive environment , Profit is Good .. SHUBH LAABH

I dont want any instructions/Rules.

Some very limited regulations which enforces accountability

Thats all , what we need.

THanks

Anonymous said...

What about manufacturing? Even with one third of population that of India, USA is suffering due to flight of manufacturing. In any society every body can not be smart enough to be employed in High Tech Service Industry. Big retailers just gets goods from world's factory ( China) and dump cheap. Just visit at any Big Retailer in USA or Europe and see your self.

Why not Indian retailers can bring cold storage and better supply chain management practices in India. Are Indian business houses are so dumb? Or they just want to cash the opportunity (just like Parle and others did in soft drink industry)?

Why we always think that some thing is good for western world ( low population, high education, wealthy - due to historic reasons, high living standard) is good for India (Huge population, low education level, very high skewed wealth distribution)?

Anonymous said...

Mr. Das, your version is at odds with some facts brought up by Sreenivasan Jain in "Truth vs Hype" on NDTV:

The cold storage sector is already open, but no one has entered it. (Why?)

The existing players say that the consumer would not be able/willing to pay the cost of refrigeration.

The kirana shop-owners he interviewed are NOT worried about loss of business.

The much-hyped creation of new jobs has not happened earlier (the actual jobs were far lesser in number.)

Most of the retail chains are running at a loss; even without having to run costly back-end operations. (Their hope was a foreign buy-out; and that's why they may be disappointed today with the freeze on FDI.) So adding the burden of back-end operations would add to the losses.

So even if the FDI is allowed, the industry would be soon talking about a bailout; like the private airlines do today.

So a familiar pattern is, start a non-viable scheme by making unrealizable projections. Later, give large concessions to stem its losses and sustain it; thus wiping out all the projected benefits.

For example, take the UDI scheme (mammoth budget, clash with existing rural database); Stadia in Delhi built for Conmen-wealth Games (no one owns them now; need a few thousand crores more to make them functional).

The entire chain EXCEPT retail was open, but only Metro entered (probably with the hope that they will "manage" to get the retail later). Clearly the retail outlet part of the entire chain is the only attractive stage.

BTW it would be too much to expect that the "for FDI" side too was not funded by interested parties.

Harmeet Kochhar said...

For my son's birth day party I did online shopping on the internet and was amazed at the results. I got fascinating return gifts at really low prices from a seller in China. Even after including shipping charges, I got a very good deal as compared to local shops. Thanks to logistics advancements, the shipments arrived in less than a fortnight.

That's a kind of freedom of choice I want in my buying experience. And if there are forieng sellers who can provide such options then we shall welcome them. Few years ago I could not have imagined to buy different items from different countries merely for a birth day party. And if these choices are made available in local shops with the help of FDI, then why not?

Similarly, I see a variety of options these days in malls on range of items from packaged juices to nappies and so on. Having juice of an exotic fruit or Brazillian coffee is like buying a local product. Most of such items have been imported by some traders in metro cities. Obviously, it generates trading business and provides more choices to end users. Why not increase such choices by opening up for more sellers.

I remember around a decade and a half ago there was very similar discussion on whether India shall sign GATT/WTO. And almost same concerns over job loss and safety of local industry were up in the political air. I am assuming that the variety of choices I experience today in market is somewhere possible because of our signing of GATT. And there does not seem to be much loss of jobs or otherwise because of GATT. In fact, political and social class have even forgotten the topic of GATT. It makes me believe that we can still go ahead with FDI in Retail, it will do good for the end-users and for serious business houses. And just like GATT, our political class will forget about FDI investment in retail also.

The political class that does not bother much about starving farmers committing suicides, they are not going to bother much about kirana store owners as well. I hope India will not loose good socio-economic opportunity for a political gimmick.

Harika said...

Dear Ankur ,

Nice Blog...

Thanks For Sharing....Keep Posting Reviews

Anonymous said...

Dear Mr. Das,
You wrote an article in Daink Bhaskar in support of FDI in retail. It was totally in support for the MNCs; ignoring to the genuine concerns of the people in general. I wrote you an e-mail & raised some 18 points against your view. I was expecting your response but even my frequent reminders couldn't draw your attention. you could not leave people confused. Please read my e-mail and answer me.
Abhishek Vaishnav

Online Training said...

Great work! Very nice blog. useful information

Anonymous said...

O mirzaio mirzay ki shakal dekho or tauba kero

http://www.hacklejackle.blogspot.com/

antique furniture said...

thank' you for information
i like it inpiratin
very good.
Best Regard
jeparaantiquefurniture.com

shwetank sharma said...

Mr. Das
I am not convinced with the reasoning you have given for sustainability of Kirana Business. First, if you contend that Kirana shops will not shut because they offer customized services(home delivery,credit) then i think we are missing a link here. Kirana provides the customized services because the kirana owner anticipates the monthly 'sauda' (monthly bulk purchase of all the grocery items) from the customers. That's why they compromise on their profitability while providing such customized services. In case foreign companies throng the market place, it will definitely affect Kirana business and prove detrimental to their high revenue monthly purchases.

Therefore, i do not support the reasoning provided for FDI in retail not affecting the Kirana.

gadgetworld said...

Buy your latest mobile online.

www.ChiCha.in said...

hii..

Nice Post Great job.

Thanks for sharing.

gwl said...

The visit was useful. Content was really very informative. visit giftwithlove dot com(portal to send gifts and flowers to India.).

health-today said...

very nice and interesting article!
everyone like it...
thanks for the information...

Anonymous said...

Abode Of luring strate'gem'
CURA'12-- A National Level Management Fest
www.cura12.com

roses said...

Sound too different..........
http://www.rosesandgifts.com

Rachit said...

The post resonates the fear of Aam Admi... was an eye opener for me.. cleared dark clouds looming over the topic.

Weakest LINK

MyGrahak said...

Where will India stand after few years is the question? What do you think about FDI in retail sector?

Divya Bhaskar
MyGrahak.com

internet marketing belgium said...

nice blog article

PWT Sports Racing News said...

Excellent blog article

PWT Health Tips said...

nice post sharing

Business economy world said...

Absolutely blog information great

internet marketing belgium said...

Interesting post

Shashank Gupta said...

I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don't know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog. I will keep visiting this blog very often.

ahmedabadonnet said...

Very well said...
ahmedabadonnet.com

anshul said...

,I am a great fan of your writings. Looking forward to your new book eagerly......

entertainment

Stock Tips said...

Excellent Post,it has a significant meaning and thanks for sharing the information.Would love to read your next post too......
Thanks
Regards
Stock Tips

Trickmaker said...

Really a good post, heart touching, this is our india. What we can do?????????Shame

Nishi said...

I really appreciate your post. It gives an outstanding idea that is very helpful for all the people on the web. Thanks for sharing this information and I’ll love to read your next post too and invite u to my blog stock tips.

YouBihar said...

Personally FDI in India could be a good thing. We need to think something out of the box. Let it come to India. It will create jobs, more infrastructure, flow of money, competition, lower prices, more goods. If China can do it, why not us. Lets not shy away from this debate and lets think about it.

price4shop said...

Check the Features and Specifications For Mobile Gadgets,laptop and etc..if u buy an online shopping..Visit More @ www.price4shop.com

Lighina VB said...

Amazing blog,keep up the good work. www.domain2host.org

ankur verma said...

Some truly good and utilitarian data on this internet internet site , likewise I feel the style and style holds amazing attributes.
songs

Sanjeev Chainani said...

It's interesting to read. Nice post.
Sanjeev Chainani

http://naturalairventindia.com/ said...

your article fanttastic. thanks in informahie.....from Industrial Ventilators bangalore

Ventilator Manufacturers bangalore

JosephFlWZ said...

nice blog article

fahad ali said...

good article really ur blog is so informative and so amzing....

tooth extracting forceps

usman ali said...

thanx dude share the post..
Needle holders,elevators kits,elevators roots,Cotton & Dressing Pliers,dental tooth extracting forceps,scissors,Syndesmotome

web design india said...

Wonderful blog & good post.Its really helpful for me, awaiting for more new post. Keep Blogging!


Web Design India

modular office furniture said...

Very nice and helpful information has been given in this article. I like the way you explain the things. Keep posting. Thanks. Furniture Stores in puna

VMX Creative dubai said...

Great work! Very nice blog. useful information

property management consultant Dubai said...

Nice blog Dude..thanks 4 share

Macnross said...

Great work

Puneflowersdelivery said...

Send flowers to Pune, flowers to Pune delivery,flowers to Pune, Pune flowers delivery, flowers Pune, Online flowers to Pune.

Exercise Me said...

Great work and Nice info

Gym in dubai

chennaicakesdelivery said...

Send cakes to chennai, cakes to chennai, cakes to chennai delivery, cakes home delivery to chennai, buy, online, same day, cake delivery to chennai

sumtech seo said...

Thanks ..Excellent article..

car rental companies uae

Flowersbangalore said...

Flowers to Bangalore; send flowers online to Bangalore and buy Birthday flowers, wedding flowers, Anniversary flowers, condolence and sympathy flowers, send same day flowers to Bangalore online with us. Buy flowers online for same day delivery in Bangalore.

saranya zinavo said...

It was a beneficial workout for me to go through your webpage.website development company

sumtech seo said...

Nice blog..Thanks

Al Nimr Steel Trading LLC is one of the best steel supplier in GCC countries like dubai,Saudi,etc.we are provide a best quality steel products like stockholders ,Ship building plates,Hot Rolled Beams and Plates at affordable prices in Dubai,UAE

Steel suppliers in Dubai

Web Development Company said...

This is the Great information:)



Web Development Company

Melinawatson said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Melinawatson said...

Very pleasant and cooperative information has been granted in this article. I like the way you interpret the things. Keep posting. Thanks.
http://plus.google.com/+AgencyescortslondonCoUkdate/.

Web Development Company said...

Very nice.. Wonderful article you are sharing.. Great.. thank you



Property Management Software

saransh khanna said...

Great post, thanks for sharing..



Wordpress Development Company

Web Design India

sumtech seo said...

bilva indian school dubai


Bilva Indian School is No1 International Shcool in Dubai,UAE

Ramana P said...

Thanks for sharing this blog i have lot of information knows thisoffice furniture manufacturers in Bangalore.

sumtech seo said...

Nice, from this blog readers will come to know about the democracy.

today i came to know many good things

thanks a lot

Ayesha Banu said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Ayesha Banu said...

thanks
raktherm solution

Ayesha Banu said...

bisedu

waiting for new updates

sumtech seo said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
India Flower said...

Really your post is too wonderful. carry on your good work and share your information from us.
Send Flowers To Bhatinda

Jacky said...

This is Great Wonderful ideas.. Thanks for sharing.. Great


Netsuite Partners

nortoncontact number said...

nice blog thank for sharing this bloghttp://www.nortoncontactnumber.co/

rachel cavanna said...

I have been through your blog and I found it very helpful for planning my travel in future and also will help in planing tour for others too.Car Hire for Agra

keerthi shekar said...

Great Work. This post is worth everyone’s attention. web design company in chennai

Shreeja K said...

Informative article, just what I was looking for.seo services chennai

telugumovie updates said...

Nice Posting Keep on update like this

Samsung Galaxy S7 Edge Smart Phone

Winwebsolutionz said...

Can truly relate and retain this outstanding post. Very well written. web design company Chennai

isiwal technologies said...

I Am Very Happy To See Your Blog And It Is Very Useful For Me And I Gathered Many Information From Your Blog Thanks For Sharing Your Blog With Us.

Victor Hugo said...

Really your post is too wonderful. carry on your good work and share your information from us.


TMT Bars Manufacturers in chennai | Steel Dealers in Chennai