Sunday, March 31, 2013

Food security bill: Corruption by another name


On the same day as the central cabinet approved the food security bill two weeks ago, Delhi’s chief minister, Sheila Dixit, stood up courageously to defend the rising price of electric power in the Delhi assembly. She explained patiently to the legislators that you cannot have something for nothing--electricity costs money and those who use it should pay for it. In the end she succeeded. By not raising the power subsidy, Delhi’s chief minister was able to increase investment for roads, public transport, education and health care in Delhi state’s annual budget.

The contrast between the two actions of the centre and the Delhi state could not have been more dramatic. Sheila Dixit’s actions will lead to productive jobs, better skills and long term prosperity of the people. The food security bill, on the other hand, will condemn India’s poor to perpetual poverty.

The proposed food security law plans to distribute grain to two thirds of India’s population at a 90% subsidy, which will cost the nation over Rs 100,000 crores.  Giving people virtually free food will keep them dependent on a ‘mai baap party’, trapping them into a permanent vote bank. It is a brilliant strategy of the Congress Party at the centre—both the voters and the party will thus have a vested interest in keeping people poor and dependent.

If the same Rs 100,000 crores were to be spent in providing public goods--roads, schools, power, and law and order--it would opportunities. It would encourage entrepreneurs to start businesses, which would create sustainable jobs and raise the state’s tax revenues. These taxes, in turn, would make it possible to invest in more public goods. Thus, a virtuous circle would be created and lift the society’s standard of living. But the Congress Party would lose out for people would move out of poverty and the party would lose its vote bank. The party needs for people to remain poor.

There are other serious risks associated with the food security bill. The fact is India just cannot afford this colossal spending. The latest budget of the central government shows how vulnerable are the nation’s finances. This new spending will increase India’s fiscal deficit and could well lead to a downgrade of the country’s sovereign rating to junk status. A downgrade of the rating will raise the cost of money available to India from the world market and also discourage foreign investment at a time when it is much needed.
Moreover, past experience shows that less than half the food in such programs reaches the intended beneficiaries. Hence, half of the 50 million tonnes of grain are likely to get diverted to the black market by this bill, and this could result in another scam which this scam tainted government cannot afford.

Worse, this bill will tempt people to lie about their financial status and weaken public morality even further. For example, 83% of Karnataka’s people call themselves poor based on BPL cards issued. But government records show that less than a quarter of the people in the state are, in fact, poor. West Bengal also discovered last year that forty percent of its BPL cards were fake. In Uttar Pradesh, the situation is much worse. A law that turns people into liars would have horrified our founding fathers. They had a profoundly moral vision of the Indian republic--so much so that they placed the wheel of dharma, the Ashok Chakra, in the nation’s flag. When a government forces its people to become dishonest, it wounds public dharma and undermines the trust between the rulers and the ruled.

When we were young our parents taught us the importance of honest and  hard work. We learned that if you did not work you did not eat. But when the government starts giving people something for nothing, it weakens the work ethic. It undermines the ethic of responsibility and dharma taught to us by our parents. When the government starts giving away to people subsidized food, diesel, cooking gas, NREGA jobs, it sends the wrong message. It teaches them that they can get something without working for it. This is another form of adharma.
The reforms of 1991 were based on an unwritten social contract which created a new basis of trust. The contract was that the government would stop running businesses and focus instead on governance and public goods. Entrepreneurs and markets would do a more efficient job of managing businesses and this would lift the economy’s growth rate. This has, indeed, been happening. As a result of high growth, almost two hundred million people have risen out of poverty and another two hundred million have joined the middle class in the past two decades.

 Thus, the private sector has done its job. But the government has not lived to its side of the bargain. It has done a very poor job of providing infrastructure. Instead of investing in roads, electricity, and other public goods, it has focused on giving ‘bribes for votes’ to the people. These bribes are subsidies on food, electric power, diesel, cooking gas, NREGA jobs etc. Unlike investment, subsidies do not result in production. When spending is not backed by production, it leads to inflation. Thus, ‘bribes for votes’ policy has contributed to inflation in our county

 Giving away virtually free food and power, waiving loans to farmers, creating ‘make work’ jobs, as the UPA government has been doing, has undermined the social contract. Markets meanwhile have helped to accelerate social change and re-shaped public character. A new class of citizens has risen who are now demanding a corruption-free state. They are angry over poor governance and corruption, and this has widened the gap between people’s aspirations and government’s performance.

The UPA’s campaign managers for the 2014 elections may think that India’s vast majority is untouched by the new dharma, but the recent protests against corruption and violence against women have shown otherwise. This cynical food security bill, instead of winning votes, may thus only add to the woes of the UPA, which will discover to its peril in 2014 that voters will think of the food security bill as amounting to corruption by a different name.
------

32 comments:

HK Joshi said...

India is having so many corrupted people. India really requires a Hitler for once.

Shashikant Nishant Sharma said...

India has become the land of corruption in recent years. Good write up.

Anonymous said...

Hi, its good piece of writing concerning media print,
we all know media is a great source of information.

My web site: Cars 4 Insurance

Anonymous said...

great issues altogether, you simply won a emblem new reader.
What may you suggest in regards to your submit that you just made a few days in the past?
Any positive?

my blog Online Dominos vouchers

Anonymous said...

We're a group of volunteers and starting a brand new scheme in our community. Your website provided us with helpful info to work on. You've performed a formidable
process and our entire group can be grateful to you.

my web-site; Http://Wiki.Dropolus.Org/Index.Php/User:SuzannaBr

Anonymous said...

Wow, wonderful blog layout! How long have you been blogging for?
you made blogging glance easy. The entire look of your web site is wonderful, as neatly as the content!


Take a look at my weblog :: free Dominos vouchers

Anonymous said...

What i do not realize is if truth be told how you're not actually much more smartly-appreciated than you may be now. You are very intelligent. You already know therefore significantly with regards to this topic, made me for my part consider it from so many numerous angles. Its like men and women don't seem to be involved
until it is one thing to accomplish with Lady
gaga! Your personal stuffs outstanding. Always deal with it up!


Also visit my web blog ... Cars 4 Insurance

Anonymous said...

Hi everyone, it's my first pay a quick visit at this website, and piece of writing is actually fruitful in support of me, keep up posting these types of posts.

Look into my web-site - dominos Discount Vouchers

Anonymous said...

The concept of social entrepreneurs making profit along with improving the society does not make sense to all. Many companies believe that they can either benefit the society or make profit. There is no doubt that sometimes effectiveness and efficiency cant be achieved together. If social enterprises start focusing on making money, their ability to serve social and environmental causes might get affected. But one also cant deny the fact that such enterprises need a strong financial backing so that they dont have to compromise on their objectives of sustainable development. Since banks are mostly risk-averse and foundations dont offer grants on easy terms, lack of finance has become the biggest hurdle for such enterprises to grow. Therefore, social entrepreneurs should try operating and thinking like commercial businessmen to some extent so that their services dont get affected due to irregular cash flow.Every woman loves her shoes. There is no greater joy than buying a new pair and wearing them all the time. With Toms this joy is doubled because when you buy the shoe, a shoeless child gets to cover his feet![url=http://www.cheaptomsbuy.com]Cheap Toms sale[/url] TOMS Shoes accepts the following forms of payment. Please be advised that they do however only accept one form of payment per order. Toms Shoes Coupons - Why Do You Need Them [url=http://www.cheaptomssite.com]Cheap Toms[/url] Toms shoes are about new to the market. You may acquire noticed them around, they accessory a little like an espadrille, but they do not acquire the cork bottoms, instead, they acquire an adaptable sole. They are an actualization of shoe admired by boyish people, and abnormally students. They acquire the abounding above of acclimation altogether the allegation for actualization and comfort. [url=http://www.tomsfans.com]Cheap Toms[/url] Where Can You Buy TOMS Shoes?
Relate Artcile

[url=http://www.neighbourhoodlink.com/board/YaBB.pl?action=viewprofile;username=Immissimi]ordercool toms women shoes for cheap price[/url]
[url=http://www.onlinegame517.com/bbs/viewthread.php?tid=383619&extra=&frombbs=1]offercool toms men [/url]

Anonymous said...

This is a topic that's close to my heart... Many thanks! Exactly where are your contact details though?

Take a look at my website: domines

Sweet Ana said...

really nice article,
i will surely try to implement the same in my activity

WIN an exclusive Royals gift hamper by registering with Rajasthan Royals

Anonymous said...

Good response in return of this question with
genuine arguments and telling the whole thing concerning that.


my blog post care home consultants

Anonymous said...

I'm really impressed with your writing talents as well as with the structure in your weblog. Is that this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way stay up the nice quality writing, it is rare to look a great blog like this one these days..

My webpage Accountant Average Salary

Anonymous said...

What's up i am kavin, its my first occasion to commenting anyplace, when i read this article i thought i could also create comment due to this brilliant piece of writing.

my web blog infidelguy.com

Anonymous said...

Hi there, of course this post is genuinely pleasant and I
have learned lot of things from it regarding blogging. thanks.


Here is my website; wybielanie zębów

Anonymous said...

We are a gaggle of volunteers and starting a brand new scheme
in our community. Your web site provided us with helpful info to work on.
You've done a formidable task and our entire group will be thankful to you.

my webpage - bezbolesne leczenie zębów

Anonymous said...

Kеep this going please, great ϳοb!


Also viѕit my webpаge ... resistor books

Anonymous said...

I like reading through an article that will make
people think. Also, thanks for allowing for me to comment!


Feel free to visit my homepage directory

Anonymous said...

Hey very interesting blog!

Also visit my webpage free stuff in manchester

Anonymous said...

It's fantastic that you are getting thoughts from this post as well as from our dialogue made at this time.

My website ... aparat RTG

Anonymous said...

Hello, I enjoy reading all of your post. I wanted
to write a little comment to support you.

Also visit my site; lampa polimeryzacyjna

Anonymous said...

Wow, awesome weblog format! How long have you been running a blog for?
you make blogging glance easy. The whole look
of your website is excellent, let alone the content material!


my homepage :: voucher codes for dominos pizza

Anonymous said...

whoah this blog is magnificent i really like studying
your articles. Keep up the great work! You know, a
lot of people are searching around for this
information, you can aid them greatly.

Feel free to visit my page cream for wrinkles

Anonymous said...

Its like you read my mind! You seem to know so much about this, like you wrote the book in it or something.
I think that you could do with a few pics to drive the
message home a bit, but instead of that, this is excellent blog.
An excellent read. I will definitely be back.

my blog - discount Vouchers For dominos

Anonymous said...

Informative article, just what I was looking for.

Also visit my website - watches For men

Anonymous said...

Goοԁ pοѕt. I leаrn ѕоmеthing tοtally new and challenging
on blogѕ I stumbleupon eveгyԁay.
It will alωays be іnteгеstіng to read аrtiсleѕ from otheг ωrіters and practice a little something from
their web sіtes.

Reviеw my blog post wire-wound Resistor

Anonymous said...

Ι love ωhаt you guyѕ arе up
tοo. This sort of clever ωork аnd coverage!

Keeρ up the νery gooԁ woгks guyѕ I've incorporated you guys to blogroll.

Also visit my web-site - Varistor Vdr 

Anonymous said...

Wоw, that's what I was exploring for, what a material! existing here at this webpage, thanks admin of this site.

Also visit my web blog Http://Madfox.Dk/Mediawiki-1.18.1/Index.Php?Title=Bruger:Edgardo63

Anonymous said...

Pгetty gгeat post. I ѕimply stumblеd
uρоn your weblog аnd wаnteԁ tо mention
that I've really loved browsing your weblog posts. After all I will be subscribing to your rss feed and I am hoping you write once more very soon!

Feel free to visit my blog Georg ohm

Karan Chopra said...

There is no doubt when government proposes new itself everytime. Planning and bringing bills just turned into another more money scandals.

Karan Chopra, Editor – I2Mag/JustWP.org

Atul said...

Dear Mr Das,
I was listening to you on NDTV on the discussions for India's Food security bill. With due respect. I was shocked on your take.
I was touring in Melbourne Australia(2005) with a very senior former Minister from Punjab government and asked his opinion on how long India will take to come to the level of Melbourne? Pat come the candid reply, never!!! I was perplexed with the response and he clarified, we have not been able to provide food and water to the majority of the population, how can we aim to become or even come close to becoming Melbourne.
After living in one of the poorest regions of Madhya Pradesh in mining industry, I could understand the full meaning of the politician's statement, I am sorry you cannot relate to sitting in the five star culture of corporate world and book writing. I am in no way a communist in thoughts and am very much supporter of free market economy with a humane angle.
Apart from the social side this food security bill has, it is a good market which will eventually be created. It is the human nature, to look for food, once this is achieved the clothes are being aimed at and then house and then it goes on ....... Let us give the sense of security to our over 1 billion strong population that the food is assured, go out and achieve the other things for which you have potential. It may be Health, sports, arts, business, charity and improve your and your family lives. Humans have unlimited potential, it is the scare of feeding themselves and their families which put them in back foot. Take away this scare and see what this race can achieve for themselves and for the nation.
Once the above is achieved the society as a whole improves. There will be better schools, hospitals, and your favourite Malls will come in a more evolutionary and gradual way, rather than Businesses and politicians putting in their ill-gotten wealth into these things. From businessman of your stature, you be the one who should have pointed the huge markets this would create. It seems you are leaving this important aspect of market for a merchant banker of Goldman Sachs to consider, project to their company, make billions and in turn gets millions in commissions. He will surely be thankful to you sir.
We have enough of politicians in our country to fight on all the issues, trust me we don’t need you. Only way you can contribute is, stick to your basics. Turn around adversity into opportunity and guide people so that they can benefit from the changes happening around. This creates jobs, individuals and Nations flourish.
There will be problems in implementing this right to food, then don’t we as humans have problem in adapting to any change that come. A tax payer will be thinking of more taxes coming their way, an imperialist will be thinking how everyone is eating food without chanting their name and the corporate world may be thinking that the labour will not come to their factories once they have food in their house. This is a myopic vision and will not do good to our society. Let us appeal to everyone who lives a life of purpose to make this food bill happen. It is a chance for everyone to participate in charity and get the solace of leading a good life.
I agree with your apprehension of fractured PDS and other scam waiting to happen when so much of money is involved. It is a humble request of the nation to come up with the solution and present it to the government. You hold a position where you are being listened to. It is your chance to participate in this landmark bill, which is more important than all the fundamental rights put together, as this, gives right to the child well before she/he is born.
Regards,
Atul Seth

Disclaimer:- I do not hold any biases against Mr Das and writing this note do not change my view that Mr. Das is a knowledgeable writer and a successful businessman.

QUALITY SERVICES said...

Nice post, I bookmark your blog because I found very good information on your blog, Thanks for sharing more informatiom
http://goo.gl/tGqfRs